Home Page      Who      What      Where      When      Why      How     

Denise Provost

Vice President - Board of Aldermen

Swearing-In Speech January 2003


At last year's inauguration ceremony, so soon after the terrible events of 9/11/01, at least three public officials made remarks about the soul. Alderman White, as incoming President of the BOA , spoke of the soul of the city itself, posing the Biblical question, What does it profit us if we gain the world, but loose our soul?

Specifically, he compared the Somerville of today to Somerville as he remembered it in 1973, a Somerville full of families and children; where people knew who their neighbors were, and looked out for each other. He expressed concern that the search for personal prosperity was jeopardizing our civic soul.

This year, Somerville is faced with an economic downturn of massive proportions. Hardship alone cannot make us a more virtuous or caring city. Yet difficulty and peril could stimulate the soul of this city in a beneficial way.

The difficulties that loom ahead are not just for Somerville. Last month the newspapers reported that our nation faces its worst fiscal situation since WW2. On top of that misfortune, we hover on the brink of a war that has the potential to become another world war.

It is my most ardent prayer at this time that our nation does not go to war.

Yet the great decisions of war and peace, and the big decisions shaping our economic recovery - or lack of it - will be made in Washington. Those of us in local government can express our desire for peaceful solutions to conflict, and for economic recovery, but our principal job is staying the course.

Our day to day work is on the 'home front,' promoting and safeguarding the health, safety, and welfare of Somerville's people. As Alderman White has revealed to me, this duty includes attention to the development - or decline - of our civic soul.

I believe the yearning we might feel to return to 1973, or to other years past, is partly a sense of missing our elders - particularly those folks who came of age during the Great Depression and World War 2 -- those my colleague Alderman Connolly refers to as "the greatest generation."

Every year, the surviving members of this generation grow fewer in number. We miss them personally. We miss the embodiment in society of the values they represent.

Additionally, we experience the unsettling knowledge that we are becoming the elders of society - 'aldermen' means 'elder men,' after all. It's worth asking what we can learn from this generation that will help us take on their role as elders, and to fulfill it honorably.

So I talked to some experts - to my parents, and to friends who lived through the Great Depression and WW2 - about what sustained people then, and brought this nation so creditably through those difficult days. Here's what they told me:

Our elders practiced thrift. They experienced rationing, cutting back, making do, using up, doing without. We can do the same. Our elders saved scrap metal, cotton rags, food, old vinyl records - for the war effort, and because they could not afford waste. We can practice less rigorous economies, and conserve much that is of value.

Our elders had a strong work ethic. They applied themselves to the tasks at hand. They took care of the young, the old, the sick, and when necessary, the wounded. They went the extra distance, spent the extra time and effort, doing what needed to be done. We are as capable as they of finding what work needs to be done in our community, and doing it.

Our elders were as generous as their circumstances permitted. "Everyone helped everyone," I've been told. Women with little to spend on food for their families managed to feed neighbors down on their luck, and even hobos. My father says that, during the Great Depression, business people, anyone with a little to spare, would hire others, not just to provide needed income, but for the dignity of purposeful labor.

Our elders made sacrifices - but here I have a confession to make. Last week, when the Somerville Journal ran an article about whether Dilboy Stadium would be funded, and the governor's spokesman's comment was that "[t]here are huge challenges ahead that will require sacrifices of us all," I got angry. I asked whoever was nearby what sacrifice Gov. Romney had ever made. I was assured that spending the winter in Massachusetts was a great sacrifice for someone was used to being out on the ski slopes of Utah.

In retrospect, I'm a bit embarrassed by this exchange. We all need to vent sometimes, but it's a mistake to get distracted by other people's behavior, whatever we think of it. Some may invoke the virtue of sacrifice for their own motives, but sacrifice does not become less noble for it.

It is the sober truth that we have all benefitted from the sacrifices of those who came before us, including those sacrifices that we justly honor as "supreme." Most of us here are unlikely to have to make the kind of sacrifices that our elders made. The least we can do is to try with grace and good humor to make some smaller sacrifices, of time, convenience, and effort, in working for the common good.

Although no one I talked to mentioned it explicitly, I think part of what helped our elders through the great challenges of their century was the feeling of being united in a common purpose. I don't mean only the war time sense of having a common enemy. I mean the notion, as valid now as it was in the past, that our world is an unpredictable place, far beyond our individual powers of control - AND WE ARE ALL IN IT TOGETHER.

If we must conceive of having a common enemy, that enemy should be Complacency, on the one hand, and Fear, on the other. Complacency leads to laziness, and abandonment of the effort to make things better. Fear leads to panic and despair. These are not helpful qualities for a community trying to rediscover the civic virtues.

Look to the left of you, the right of you, in front of you, in back of you, at yourself, in this room, and on your street. We are the solution. We are neighbors. Each one of us has a family. Somerville is still a city of families, a city of children. Not all families look like the typical family did in 1973, but love and relationship remain.

Some of us are grown-up children, taking care of aging parents. Some of us live without children, some have grown children. Some of us have young children - look at the streets around our schools weekday mornings if you doubt that this is still a city of children.

We have all the diverse needs of a diverse community, but we also have the human resources necessary to fill those needs. We still have material wealth, the legacy of many years of material wealth.

We have also the legacy of good example that has taken us from colony to commonwealth, from remote outpost to the most powerful among nations in roughly two hundred years. I feel confident that we can apply this magnificent inheritance to the demands of today.

Denise Provost
Vice President
Board of Aldermen


Denise Provost, Alderman-at-Large, Somerville, MA

denise@provost-citywide.org


Send a comment to Denise

     Home Page      Who      What      Where      When      Why      How